fix: differentiate philosophers_stone from eternal_flame and buff crystal_shard #144

Closed
opened 2026-03-25 14:16:43 -07:00 by hikari · 0 comments
Owner

Problem

philosophers_stone is strictly dominated by eternal_flame:

  • philosophers_stone: 2.25× click + 1.25× gold
  • eternal_flame: 2.25× click + 1.1× combat + 1.25× gold

eternal_flame has all the same stats as philosophers_stone plus an additional 1.1× combat bonus. There is no reason to ever equip philosophers_stone if eternal_flame is available. They are both trinkets from the same acquisition tier.

crystal_shard (volcanic_forger set trinket) is weaker than a lower-tier purchasable:

  • crystal_shard: 1.55× click + 1.1× gold
  • void_compass (shadow_infiltrator set, costs only 350 essence): 1.6× click

A trinket that is part of an epic boss-drop set should not have a lower primary stat than a cheap purchasable from an earlier tier.

Fix

  • philosophers_stone: raise click to 2.5× to give it a clear identity as the click-specialist trinket
  • crystal_shard: raise click to 1.65× to exceed the void_compass and justify its boss-drop acquisition

This issue was created with help from Hikari~ 🌸

## Problem **`philosophers_stone` is strictly dominated by `eternal_flame`:** - `philosophers_stone`: 2.25× click + 1.25× gold - `eternal_flame`: 2.25× click + 1.1× combat + 1.25× gold `eternal_flame` has all the same stats as `philosophers_stone` plus an additional 1.1× combat bonus. There is no reason to ever equip `philosophers_stone` if `eternal_flame` is available. They are both trinkets from the same acquisition tier. **`crystal_shard` (volcanic_forger set trinket) is weaker than a lower-tier purchasable:** - `crystal_shard`: 1.55× click + 1.1× gold - `void_compass` (shadow_infiltrator set, costs only 350 essence): 1.6× click A trinket that is part of an epic boss-drop set should not have a lower primary stat than a cheap purchasable from an earlier tier. ## Fix - `philosophers_stone`: raise click to **2.5×** to give it a clear identity as the click-specialist trinket - `crystal_shard`: raise click to **1.65×** to exceed the void_compass and justify its boss-drop acquisition ✨ This issue was created with help from Hikari~ 🌸
naomi closed this issue 2026-04-06 19:33:06 -07:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Label
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: nhcarrigan/elysium#144